Monday, April 6, 2009

High Church vs. Contemporary Worship

I had a revelation this weekend about church, fitting since it is the week before Easter, and I thought I would share.

So I went to the lake this weekend with my parents. Very nice. Very relaxing. Anyway, whenever they go to the lake, since it's near Tulsa and they get the Tulsa stations, they like to watch Boston Avenue United Methodist Church on Sunday mornings live. They just love the pastor there, Mouzon Biggs (is that not a fun name or what?) and I swear if they could get up the energy to drive to Tulsa every Sunday morning to go to this church they would. I have occassionally watched it with them and I have to agree...it's good.

Let me first off tell you something about this pastor, Dr. Biggs. I have never met him before in my life. I don't even know if I've seen him in person or not. But I can just tell he is so genuine and has a sincere and deep love for people and for God. As sad as it is, it can be hard to find genuine pastors in this day and age, ones who really love what they do, are inspired every day by God's love, and aren't just going through the motions or trying to get a continuous flow of monetary funds donated to their church to keep it afloat. Mouzon Biggs embodies what a true pastor and true follower of Christ should be. Every time I see him on TV I am so inspired. Kudos to you, Mouzon Biggs, and I hope I get the chance to meet you someday. Rock on.

Anyway, on to my point of this post. Watching Boston Avenue on Monday morning got me thinking about the differences in church services, and which ones I find most appealing. I believe religion and spirituality to be a very personal thing. Something between a person and a higher power, whoever that may be. For me, it is God and his son, Jesus Chirst. I believe in the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. I believe that God sent his only son to die on the cross in forgiveness of our sins. I believe in heaven and hell, angels and demons, creation and evolution, the Bible as the Holy Word of God, the taking and receiving of Communion, being Baptised...the whole bit. I was raised in the Methodist Church and have experimented with different forms of Christianity, from being a "Bible-Thumping" "born-again" Christian to a strictly "spiritual" person to anything in between. I'm still trying to figure out for myself my relationship with God and what religion means to me in this life. But that's a whole other blog post.

It's taking me a while to get to my point, but I'll get there.

As I said, I was raised in the Methodist Church, and I believe that is where I will stay. It fits me. It has just the right amount of tradition, ritual, tolerance, and everything else that I look for in a church. But I have to be honest when there was a time in my life I hated the Church and all it stood for. I loved God and Christ, and I still worshiped in my own way, but I had just gotten so fed up with the hypocricy and the superficiality of the church. The way it was run like a business, the way people seemed to forget the true meaning of going to church, the way people seemed so fake the moment they walked into that sanctuary, like they all had something to hide. I hated how church became a place to see and be seen. I thought to myself, "this is not why God created man to worship" "this is not what Christianity is about" or the best, "how can these people stand up there and preach to me and tell me to live a certain way and pray a certain way when they are just as sinful as I am?" For a while, I just didn't get it. It was too complicated. So I didn't go. I stayed home, sang songs along with K-Love or CDs I had, read passages from my Bible every once in a while, and prayed in solitude. I've come around over the years, and I've made peace with it. I go to church, I enjoy being there, and I get it now. I get that a church is a community, it is for people to come together on common ground to worship and to be one with God. It can be a beautiful thing if done in the right way.

This is all leading up to my main big point - the difference between High Church and Contemporary Worship services, and which one best fits me. As I watched Boston Avenue on Sunday morning, saw the rows and rows of people dressed in their Sunday best, saw the preachers with their robes, watched the children light the alter candles and open the large Bible up to the verses that the sermon would be over for the day, saw the lovely choir and orchestra make beautiful music, and just saw the majesty of it all, I was taken aback. It was so...nice. And I realized in that moment how much I appreciate the traditional "High Church." For those who may not know, "High Church" is a term used to describe what we may refer to as a traditional worship service. It is the ones our grandparents went to, and for many, our parents. Many of us don't really experience High Church anymore, either because of one's denomination or simply their preference. Whereas a contemporary worship service is more high tech, laid back, wear your jeans and nice top and come read words off big screens while drinking your morning coffee, with an electric guitar and drums (nothing wrong with this type of service, I like these services on, say, Tuesday nights for Lifestream ;-) eh?) a "High Church" service is complete with nice dress, robes, "ritual." It's where people repeat prayers back to each other, repeat chants, when someone finishes reading a verse and says "This is the Word of the Lord," the congregation responds with "Thanks be to God." Things of that nature. It's usually held in a beautiful sanctuary with a large organ and stained glass windows. It reminds me of the giant cathedrals of Europe, so galant, so exquisite. That...is "High Church." And it was while watching this service at Boston Avenue that I realized how deep my appreciation goes for this type of traditional service, and that I grew up going to these types of services. I didn't get it when I was little. I thought that part of church was boring. All I could think of was getting out of there and getting to eat or go to Sunday School. I was the kid who got caught playing cards on the TV camera and who's mother was told "Emily really shouldn't be playing cards in church, it gives off perceptions of gambling and it's just rude." (True story...really happened.) Church when I was little was a time to poke my brothers, play with Mommy's jewelry, and wiggle around in my seat until my mom patted my legs as a signal to settle down and pay attention. But now, now it has a whole new meaning. It is our gift to God after all He has given us. One day a week we dress in our best and walk into a beautiful sanctuary and lift up praise and thanks to God Almighty. Church, sanctuary, our Heaven here on Earth. The best we can do anyway.

Like I said, there is nothing wrong with a contemporary worship service. But I have to wonder - what has caused this great shift in church services today? What with these huge modern churches with their big television screens, full bands, folding chairs, and 4 different "campuses." What happened to the elegance? The attempts at creating a type of Heaven on earth? A true sanctuary complete with intricate stainglass windows, beautiful paintings, and breathtaking architecture? What has changed in our society that makes us create such a simple way of worship? I admit there are times when I fully enjoy it. I get to lay back, relax, just be. But there is something about picking out a pretty Easter dress with frills and floral prints and matching hat and socks. There is something about seeing the families all dressed up at restaurants at noon on Sundays, where you know those people went to church this morning. There is something lovely and holy about walking into a large sanctuary and hearing a beautiful choir sing and repeating the Lord's prayer in unison. It is extravagant yet simple. They way God wanted it to be. God gives us so much. So why not give the best of ourselves one day a week in praise to Him?

Just an observation. Still kind of mulling over it, as you can tell from this long, jumbled post. My apologies. Hope you enjoyed!

Peace, Love, and Church

No comments: